Hi Paul,
It is not possible to recreate 'insiders/BCSG' type free exchange of information on a public forum... those involved would either act like a clam or go away!..
Such are the problems of a website.. much knowledge is second hand, or obtained by expanding on another's theory.. therefore not your own and suitable for dissemination..
You contributed to 'The Carp' for a few years and know the score..

I wouldnt mind paying a small fee for subscription but there may be others who dont agree with me

Paul, why don't you create a poll on the main carp forum and see what peoples views are?