Blimey Paul - you've opened up a can of worms here haven't you - something to moan about thats not spelt ECHO!!
The BCSG sounds an excellent idea to me, I probably woudn't meet the standard, however.
Surely the knockers here must realise, that man is by nature gregarious, and needs to form groups and 'gangs'. On here for instance 'the Grimsby lads', elsewhere 'the hooded fellowship' and the 'Carp Park' boys on RMC; absolutely nothing wrong with this, I don't suppose they realise it, but these loose groupings are not that different from the BCSG, they are about the sharing of information and anecdotes, they just meet in a more informal way!
'The Freemasons of Carp Angling', not quite so sinister as that lot me thinks!!
Regards
Russ